“When Love Isn’t Enough: Should Family Caregivers Be Paid?”

Caregiving is an act of love—but should it also be a paid job?

Every day, millions of Americans put their own lives on hold to care for aging parents, disabled spouses, or chronically ill children. They manage medications, coordinate doctor’s appointments, cook meals, clean homes, and provide emotional support—all without a paycheck. In many cases, they also give up full-time work, drain savings, and put their own health at risk.

We’re told, “Family takes care of family.” But what happens when that devotion becomes financially unsustainable?

It’s time to ask the hard question: Should family caregivers be paid?

The Hidden Workforce

According to AARP, unpaid family caregivers provided an estimated $600 billion worth of care in the U.S. in 2021. That’s more than the entire federal Medicaid budget.

Yet most of these caregivers receive no financial compensation, no benefits, no retirement contributions—nothing but stress and exhaustion. Many are middle-aged women juggling full-time caregiving with part-time work and parenting, forced into early retirement or bankruptcy as a result.

Is it still “volunteering” when there’s no other option?

The Emotional Minefield

This isn’t just about economics—it’s about emotion.

Families often avoid the money conversation because it feels taboo or selfish. “You should want to help,” they say. “You’re doing this out of love.” But love doesn’t pay the mortgage or cover your health insurance when you leave your job to care full-time.

Even bringing up compensation can spark resentment from siblings, spouses, or other relatives who aren’t pitching in. It creates a tension between duty and dignity—between wanting to be there, and needing to survive.

But What If It Was Normalized?

In some states, Medicaid programs do allow family members to be paid as caregivers—but the systems are complicated, the eligibility is strict, and many families don’t even know it’s an option.

What if we flipped the script?

What if, instead of treating family caregiving as invisible labor, we recognized it as essential healthcare work?

  • What if caregivers received stipends or tax credits?

  • What if families created contracts to outline expectations and payments?

  • What if caregivers had access to paid respite, retirement planning, and mental health care—just like professional home aides?

The Bottom Line

Caregiving out of love and duty is beautiful. But it doesn’t mean it should come at the cost of your health, finances, or future.

It’s not greedy to ask, “What is my time and sacrifice worth?”

It’s responsible. It’s honest. And it’s a conversation more families—and more policymakers—need to be having.

At Awaregiver, we believe that caring for others shouldn’t mean abandoning yourself.
Let’s keep talking, challenging assumptions, and reshaping the future of caregiving—one hard question at a time.

Back to blog